Software Engineering
October 16, 2025

Pomona College Supplemental Essays: A Strategic 2025-26 Guide + Winning Examples

Updated on
October 16, 2025
All
Bachelors
Commonapp
Guides

Pomona College asks applicants to respond to one of the following three short-answer prompts in 250 words or fewer.

Pomona is home to a diverse community of faculty, staff and students who, through close ties and collaboration, enable each other to identify and explore their greatest passions. Considering this, respond to one of the following:

Prompt 1: Your Community

Reflecting on a community that you are a part of, what values or perspectives from that community would you bring to Pomona?

Q: What's the real goal here?

A:

  • This prompt tests your self-awareness. It's not about the community itself, but about a specific value you learned there.
  • They want to see how you will contribute to their collaborative environment. Your value must be an active one.

Q: How do you choose your community?

A:

  • Think small and specific. "My family" is broad. "My family's Sunday dinner debates" is specific and intriguing.
  • Consider non-traditional communities: your D&D group, the regulars at your coffee shop job, a niche online forum.

Q: What's a winning structure?

A:

  • The Value: Start by naming the specific value (e.g., "constructive disagreement," "shared curiosity").
  • The Story: Tell a brief, one-sentence story that shows this value in action within your community.
  • The Bridge to Pomona: Explain how you will apply this specific value in a Pomona setting (a classroom, a club, a dorm).

Q: What should you avoid?

A:

  • Generic values like "hard work" or "perseverance." These are too common and hard to prove in a short response.
  • Simply describing the community without connecting it to a personal value you will bring to campus.
  • Refine your story to be more specific and impactful.

Example Essay:

My most cherished community gathers around a table littered with tiny screws, soldering irons, and brightly colored keycaps. We build custom mechanical keyboards. From this group, I would bring the value of patient, collaborative troubleshooting to Pomona.

I learned this value the night my friend Leo’s keyboard build went silent. We spent four hours hunched over the circuit board, desoldering and resoldering 87 tiny switches, passing a magnifying glass between us. There was no frustration, only a shared, quiet focus. When we finally found the faulty connection, the collective sigh of relief was more satisfying than any solo achievement.

At Pomona, I hope to bring this same spirit to late-night study groups and collaborative labs. I see myself leaning over a physics problem set with a classmate, not just searching for my own answer, but patiently working with them to find the faulty connection in our combined understanding. I believe the most profound discoveries aren’t made in a flash of individual genius, but through the shared, steady process of finding and fixing a problem together.

Prompt 2: An Experience

Describe an experience you had outside the classroom that changed the way you think or how you engage with your peers. What was that experience and what did you learn from it?

Q: What's the real goal here?

A:

  • To see your capacity for growth and reflection. The experience itself matters less than the change it caused in you.
  • They want to see that you are an active learner who can find meaning in everyday life.

Q: How do you choose an experience?

A:

  • Focus on a small, specific moment. A single conversation can be more powerful than a two-week trip.
  • Choose a story that shows a clear "before" and "after" in your thinking or behavior. The change must be significant.

Q: What's a winning structure?

A:

  • Before: Briefly describe your old way of thinking in one sentence.
  • The Moment: Describe the specific event or conversation that challenged your perspective.
  • After: Clearly state your new way of thinking and show it in action. How do you engage with peers differently now?

Q: What should you avoid?

A:

  • Simply describing the event without explaining the internal change. The reflection is the most important part.
  • A story where you were just a passive observer. You need to be an active participant in your own growth.
  • Ensure your reflection is clear and compelling.

Example Essay:

I used to believe that every problem had a solution, and my job was to provide it. My job at a local grocery store, specifically a conversation with a man trying to return a melted carton of ice cream without a receipt, taught me otherwise.

Store policy was clear: no receipt, no refund. I recited the rule, but the man only grew more frustrated. He wasn't yelling about the ice cream, but about his bad day, the traffic, the heat. In that moment, I realized he didn’t need a solution; he needed to be heard. I stopped talking and just listened. After a minute, he sighed, nodded, and said, “I know you can’t do anything. Thanks anyway.”

Before this, I treated disagreements in group projects as debates to be won. Now, my first instinct is to listen. I’ve learned that validating someone’s perspective is the first step toward collaboration. I now understand that the most effective way to engage with my peers isn’t always to solve the problem, but to first acknowledge the person.

Prompt 3: How Others See You

Choose any person or group of people in your life and share how they would describe you.

Q: What's the real goal here?

A:

  • This is a creative way to test your self-awareness. Can you see yourself from the outside?
  • It's an opportunity to reveal a character trait not found elsewhere in your application.

Q: Who should you choose?

A:

  • Pick someone who highlights a surprising but positive quality. Your D&D group might describe your creativity; your younger sibling might describe your patience.
  • Avoid generic choices like "my teachers" unless they can offer a very specific and unique perspective.

Q: What's a winning structure?

A:

  • The Person & The Trait: "My grandmother would describe me as a patient archivist."
  • The Proof: Tell a very brief story or give a specific example that shows why they would say this.
  • The Insight: Briefly explain what this trait says about you.

Q: What should you avoid?

A:

  • Simply listing adjectives. "My friends would say I'm kind, loyal, and funny" is a weak response. You must prove it with a mini-story.
  • Choosing a perspective that repeats a main theme of your application (e.g., if your main essay is about soccer, don't choose your coach).
  • Turn your traits into a compelling narrative.

Example Essay:

The members of my high school’s stage crew would describe me as the “quiet problem-solver.” They wouldn’t tell you about a big speech I gave, but about the little things that happen backstage.

They would probably point to the final dress rehearsal for our production of Grease. Ten seconds before the curtain rose, the hand-jive scene was plunged into darkness when the extension cord for the jukebox prop came unplugged. As the stage manager began to panic, I was already army-crawling behind the set, plugging it back in just as the first note of music hit. I didn’t get applause, just a grateful nod from our lead actress.

I believe the crew sees me this way because I find satisfaction not in the spotlight, but in making sure the spotlight works for others. It’s a form of leadership that isn’t about giving orders, but about quietly ensuring the show can go on. I value being the person who sees a problem and simply, reliably, fixes it.

All the best!